Scottish Ale Crash Course

by Billy Broas



Welcome to another beer style crash course video giving you quick but thorough explanations of beer styles.

If IPAs are for the hop heads, Scottish ales are for the malt heads. Their rich, sweet, caramel maltiness makes these highly addictive brews.

Unlike English beers which have fruity flavors from the yeast, Scottish ales are fermented cool (it’s cold there) which reduces the fruity esters and gives a very clean flavor.

A long boiling process creates the caramel flavors that are so coveted in Scottish ales. Peat malt is often used by breweries recreating the style, but it wasn’t traditionally used by Scottish brewers. The peat malt went to the distilleries and the brewers relied on their yeast, process, and other ingredients to create the beer’s complex flavors.

History of the Scottish Ale

Early Scottish beers were gruit, beers that used herbs and spices instead of hops. The heather flower is abundant in Scotland and was a common ingredient.

Scotch whiskey drinkers are well aware of the quality of malt produced in Scotland. The huge whiskey market means there was  plenty of barley for brewing beer, and they weren’t stingy with it. The brewers used high malt bills which are responsible for the malty sweet flavors of these beers.

An interesting feature of Scottish ales is their naming convention, which is based on the Shilling system of currency. The stronger the beer, the more Shillings it was taxed (actually other beers were taxed the same way, but it really stuck with Scottish ales). The lighter beers were charged 60 Shillings while the stronger ones were charged 70,80, or 90 Shillings. Here’s the BJCP breakdown if you’re brewing to style:

  • Scottish Light 60/- (2.5 – 3.2% abv)
  • Scottish Heavy 70/- (3.2 – 3.9% abv)
  • Scottish Export 80/- (3.9 – 5.0% abv)
  • Scotch Ale aka Wee Heavy – (6.5 – 10% abv)

Now for some commercial examples:

Scottish Ale

  • Orkney Dark Island
  • Bellhaven Scottish Ale
  • McEwan’s Scottish Ales
  • Three Floyd’s Robert the Bruce

Scotch Ale/Wee Heavy

  • Orkney SkullSplitter
  • Bellhaven Wee Heavy
  • Oskar Blues Old Chub
  • Founders Dirty Bastard

While doing this video I was disappointed at how hard it was to find Scottish ales, especially lower abv varieties since there are a decent amount of wee heavies out there. They are unique beers and a refreshing break from the onslaught of hops in American craft beers.

Do we have any malt heads out there? What are your favorite Scottish ales?

Click Here to Read the Transcript

billybrew-hba-banner

{ 23 comments… read them below or add one }

Jeff February 25, 2011 at 12:07 pm

Well done, Billy…I’ll have to pick some up over the weekend.

Reply

Billy Broas February 25, 2011 at 10:08 pm

Thanks buddy. You better get ready for the brews I’m going to show you in a few weeks.

Reply

Jorge - Brew Beer And Drink It February 25, 2011 at 2:55 pm

Great video!… I like Scotch ales as much as IPA’s… my favorite by far is brewed by Traquair House…

Reply

Billy Broas February 25, 2011 at 10:10 pm

Thanks Jorge. I wish Scotch ales were as available as IPAs. They’re an amazing style. I read about Traquair House in one of Michael Jackson’s books. Must try it.

Reply

Andy February 28, 2011 at 4:31 pm

Beauty!! A man after my own heart, Billy. Great job there, and my favorite style to boot. Thanks for that.

Have you tried Erie Ol’ Red Cease and Desist (from Erie Brewing, PA)? When it warms a bit, it smells like an opened package of DME. Sick! Wonderfully malty, and one of the sweeter wees around. AleSmith also makes a mighty fine one if you can grab a wine bottle of it. Really nice.

I’m pleased that you took a stance on the peat factor. While a bit of smokiness from barley and caramelization can be a part of Scottish/Scotch ales (good to point out the difference there–Nice call!), Scots brewers didn’t traditionally use peat malt. So many expect it in Scots ales and are disappointed when it’s absent (they feel it’s not true to style without it); I believe the word “Scotch” confuses things for these folks. That said, good of you to bring this to light.

Another base malt for Scottish/Scotch ales would be Simpson’s Golden Promise, the Scots equivalent of England’s Maris Otter; from what I’ve read, GP may be a touch sweeter (possibly) than MO for a base malt.

Another great bit of education for those not in the know about this highly regarded but oft-overlooked style. Keep at ‘em, and thanks.

Reply

Billy Broas March 2, 2011 at 10:05 pm

Hey Andy, thanks for the kind words. I haven’t had Cease and Desist but I do love the smell of DME. Much better than the smell of LME in my opinion. Will have to seek out that brew as well as AleSmith’s which I’ve heard a lot about.

As far of the peat, I think you’re right that the “Scotch” term confuses people. Ray Daniels actually has a pretty good section in “Designing Great Beers” that I meant to include in the post but will just put here:

“Since the barley for making whiskey is quite different from that for making beer, it is likely that preparation of the two diverged long ago. Noonan related that, even among Scots brewers, the old timers can only remember one ale that posses the peat smoke flavor, or reek, as it is called. This beer was produced for several decades during the 1900s but was discontinued in the mid 1940s.

“In his 1847 text on Scottish brewing and malting, Roberts specifies that malt kilns be fired with coke, charcoal, culms, or wood. This indicates that peat-smoked character would not have been part of Scotch or Scottish-style ale flavor during the 19th century. Given this fact, I cannot help but wonder if the use of peat in malt kilns was an extreme measure adopted during the world wars early in the 20th century.”

Pretty interesting stuff. Personally, I’m not a huge fan of smoke but I always stay to trust your taste buds so if you like that flavor go for it. I just think it’s good to get the history correct.

Anyways, thanks for the comment. You’re right, it’s an overlooked style but a great one.

Reply

Odyssey Ales February 28, 2011 at 8:50 pm

Nice article,
Youre right they are undervalued here, and the fact that they vary so much in alcohol and character makes them a little difficult to pigeon hole. As for some suggestions, I have enjoyed a lot of Broughton’s beers, their champion double ale is great. Harvestoun makes some great ales, of all varities, although I am partial to their Old Engine Oil, (not strictly speaking a Scottish Ale, but worth finding, especially if you can get the whickey cask aged versions, Ola Dubh). I enjoyed a few beers from the Isle of Skye Brewery, especially their Red Cuillin, but I lived in scotland and I am not sure how easy it is to get them over here, but if you can find them they are worth the effort.
I am afraid too often the beers labelled scotch ale in north america are a pale imitation lacking a bit of character. It seems like sometimes that they are a bit lazy when making them, and sort of view them as a normal beer with minimal hops, rather than really crafting the malt character. I had a recent rant about that on my blog, http://odysseyales.blogspot.com/2011/02/wee-bee-in-my-bonnet.html Let me know what you think.

Odyssey Ales

Reply

Billy Broas March 2, 2011 at 10:16 pm

Just left a comment on your post. Great stuff!

I haven’t had the Ola Dubh but actually just saw it at my beer store so I’ll have to pick it up. That Wee Beast in the picture is an Isle of Sky beer. It must have been an infected bottle because there was a sharp tart flavor. Too bad because I’m sure it’s great closer to where it’s brewed, which is also a problem when tasting these beers from overseas. I think a trip is in order.

Reply

Nels March 6, 2011 at 7:42 pm

Great video, thanks Billy. Northern Brewer has a few Scottish ale kits, and now I think I may consider one for the next batch…

Reply

Billy Broas March 7, 2011 at 10:32 am

Awesome Nels. After doing this video I also got the bug to brew one and made an 80/- this weekend. Let us know how yours turns out!

Reply

Lisa Kristine March 8, 2011 at 3:14 am

Great video, just had to throw a recommendation for my fav scotch ale, the Fat Woody by Silver City Brewery, I just did a review of it on my very newly created blog and it is fantastic!

Reply

Royce March 9, 2011 at 8:00 pm

I am indeed a malt head, and love all the beers you’ve listed. I also have Kilt Lifter on that list of fairly typical examples of a Scotch ale. Or is it Scottish? Will have to look it up. That’s a terrible naming convention by the way… wayyy too similar sounding.

Old Chub is too cloying for my taste. It is one dimensional in a way. The Highway 78 is a revelation, however. Like we’ve talked about, it is like one extra oomph from greatness.

Reply

Stephen Martin July 13, 2011 at 6:13 pm

We have a brewery here in Ft Worth called “Rahr & Sons” . They have a seasonal Scottish Ale (Iron Thistle) which is an award winner. Unfortunately it is not distributed nationwide. It would be classified as a “Wee heavy”, having around 8% ABV, but it is a dark and lucious brew. It is also unfortunate that as a seasonal, it is only available here in Jan-Feb.

Reply

David in FL October 18, 2011 at 6:36 am

Great video and Scotch ales are definitely one of my favorite styles. I enjoy the whole range from light to heavy. I really dig French Broad Brewery’s Wee Heavy-er ( NC ).

Just curious why no mention of the characteristic carbonation typical of Scotch Ales?

Reply

Billy Broas October 18, 2011 at 9:08 am

Glad you enjoyed it David. There was a lot more I could have said about the style (like the carbonation) but to keep the videos short I leave a lot out. I felt I was already pushing the “crash course” theme with this one. Good to hear I held your attention the whole way through though!

Reply

neal! March 27, 2012 at 9:28 pm

Liked your article. A nice 80 sh/ innis & Gunn Irish whiskey cask Scottish ale is good one.
The aged whiskey. Cask adds a nice flavor.

Reply

Billy Broas March 27, 2012 at 10:12 pm

Thanks Neal. Cheers.

Reply

Phil Dubya August 23, 2012 at 2:41 pm

I just bottled my first scotch Ale, I remember years ago a friend of mine came back from scotland and brought me back some mcewans , Best beer I can I ever remember tasting. I bought some and it didnt even come close. I guess the export was different or sat way too long in poorlly controlled environments. I hope I am able to get at least close to what I tatsed back then.

Reply

Peggy Noland March 26, 2013 at 7:15 pm

Great and informative video! A wonderful local brewery, St George Brewing Co. In Hampton, Virginia, makes the absolutely delicious St George Winter Scotch Ale (6% ABV 25 IBU)…the favorite in our kegerator!

Reply

Billy Broas March 27, 2013 at 9:21 am

Thanks Peggy. I used to live in that area and had St. George’s many times, but I don’t think I had the Scotch Ale. Will have to look out for it.

Reply

Ron Pattinson July 18, 2013 at 4:47 am

Unfortunately most of what you say about the history of Scottish beer isn’t true.

The shilling number wasn’t the tax, it was the wholesale price per hogshead.

Scottish beer wasn’t fermented any cooler than English beer. Both fermented at between 60º and 75º F.

Scottish brewers didn’t use long boils. In fact in the 109th century they had very short boils, often not much more than 1 hour. Not only weren’t they aiming for kettle carmelisation, they were doing their best to avoid it because they wanted to keep the colour of the beer as pale as possible, That’s the reason why, like Burton brewers, they had open coppers, whereas London Porter brewers had closed coppers.

60/-, 70/- and 80/- in their current form only really date from after WW II. They’re all basically Pale Ales.The shilling Ales of the 19th century were a completely different style, a sort of Mild Ale, but concentrating on the higher end of the strength spectrum. 80/-, 100/, 110/-, 120/-, 140/- and 160/- ranging from 6% to 10% ABV.

In the second half of the 19th century many of the Edinburgh brewers used virtually no Scottisdh ingredients at all, other than water. They bought their barley from East Anglia and their hops from England, the USA, Germany and Bohemia. William Younger was a big fan of Saaz and used them in their Pale Ales.

In the 19th century Scottish beers were as heavily-hopped as those in England. Low-hooping only seems to date from the 20th century.

Scottish brewers used virtually no coloured malts other than in Stout. The colour in other beers usually came from caramel, often added at racking time. Some brewers would have as many as a dozen differnt-coloured versions of the same beer, each made for a specific town or region.

How do I know this? Because I’ve taken the time to look through hundreds of Scottish brewing records, dating from the 1830’s to the 1990’s.

The Scottish beers you describe are basically an American invention with little connection to the beers actually brewed in Scotland.

Reply

Jonathan May 7, 2014 at 2:41 pm

http://alesmith.com/beers/wee-heavy/

Link to the award-winning Alesmith Wee Heavy, YUM – their brewery is right by where I live!

Reply

Ron August 28, 2014 at 7:58 pm

Stone Arch Brewery in Appleton Wisconsin makes an outstanding Scotish Ale.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: